Yesterday, a hard decision was reached, one which I had personally fought against for months. However, I have found that as I tried to ignore a rule that was present on Unity, one that stated that off-topic chatter should be kept to the proper areas, I found that it became harder to give people distinguished lines on what was acceptable and what was not. Trolls were flooding the topics, both friendly and fun and non-friendly. The lines were just blurring and the modding appeared to be inconsistent.
Anyway, I’m about to rant a lot, so I’m going to put a more here.
Some spoke out on the influx of trolling activities and off-topic chatter, and their complaints were not unheard. Thus, the topic was brought up to the other mods for discussion, and in the end, I had to agree that there was not a point in a MH Tri board if no one was speaking about MH Tri.
Still, it should be noted that for months, I had been attempting to accommodate the wishes of the community and provide an area for MH members to go off-topic outside of a single topic. I personally feel that one topic is just too cluttered and not a proper way to permit others to speak openly and have off-topic conversations. It’s like stuffing everyone inside of a crowded small lunch room and telling them that they must stay there forever and hold conversations over everyone else.
I personally wanted for an off-topic sub-section for Monster Hunter. However, this was never meant to be.
As proof of my attempts throughout the months:
Subject: Question about MH board
Sent: Jul 29, 10:02AM
I’ve been thinking, a lot of other game boards and sites have at least an OT topic for people to just come in and get to know each other without pulling the other topics off course. Would it be reasonable to start one in the Tri Forum?
The reason this came to mind is because I’ve regularly seen topics stray aside, and have done such myself, to adress a side-topic or another person. Hence, I think an official OT topic would be smart. However, I’m not brave enough to start it…
Thanks for your time, Snow.
Received: Thu, Jul 29, 2010 at 12:41pm
We have an entire group forum called “General Off Topic” just for such things.
Even Snow was adamant that the General Off-Topic was sufficient for all Off-Topic conversation. All other attempts to bring up this sort of issue came with the same responses. Meanwhile, those from the community voiced that the General Off-Topic section was “blegh”, “scary”, and other such things. I personally sympathize with their opinions. Being forced to go off-topic with people that you don’t know and are uncomfortable with is indeed “scary”. Especially when you wanted to talk to the community that you know and love.
Anwyay, I’m done speaking of how much I failed in my attempts to permit for an off-topic area for my beloved Monster Hunters. I’d probably ramble on forever if I didn’t stop myself.
All I know is that the enforcement that has been decided on will make people unhappy. However, the moderation members have to be consistent in our moderating. Thus, we can’t pick and choose the rules we like and dislike any more.
Hate it if you wish, I am evil and thus can easily accept the role of the bad-guy.
2 thoughts on “I’m going to speak candidly for a few moments.”
Seferia, I honestly believe you and a few other mods (CHUMP and Moropa come to mind) should be the only ones allowed to Mod the MH forums. You guys participate in the discussions and even game with and get to know the small Unity MH community. Therefore the boards and any decisions reguarding them should only be between you guys. You know what is best and I for the most part trust your judgement.
That convo with Snow was over 2 years ago. Try again with GregMan or whoever is “in charge” these days.
That was an example of one of my earliest attempts at trying to get an off-topic area for MH. Trust me, I’ve had conversations with Gregaman and others as well.
Network moderators can go to all sections. But they should defer first to those that are usually there. I am currently helping out the RE section because their mods are having issues. So, that’s why you can see network moderators all over the place. However, the mods that tend to be in a section get first say.